Assessing Learning — The Final Step

The final step in the training process is the assessment or evaluation of participant learning. Assessments measure and document participants’ acquisition of skills and knowledge. To measure the effectiveness of the training, some courses supply a pre-course assessment. The pre-test results create a baseline. Any improvements participants show on their post-course assessment scores are a direct result of the training they received.

Assessments should not be an afterthought in course design and delivery. To accurately measure training effectiveness, assessments need to be aligned with the course learning outcomes. Once the learning outcomes are identified, it is good practice to outline the assessment technique most appropriate to measure their mastery. Then, design instructional and practice activities so participants can successfully complete the assessments. See Using the Outcome Verb to Make Instructional Decisions.

The traditional multiple-choice final exam is the most used assessment tool. However, there are several other options that might be better suited to measure the skills, tasks, and behaviors expected in the learning outcomes:

Example

A multiple-choice test would not be the best way to measure achievement of the learning outcomes for the Arizona Department of Transportation “Flagger Certification Training Course.” A performance assessment is a better option. An assessment checklist or rubric can be used to document participants’ motions during the assessment activity. During his NHI “Instructor Development Course” training presentation, Edgard Baltodano provided props (paper copies of the Slow/Stop paddle) so participants could demonstrate the motions while he observed the sequence and clarity of the gestures.

Figure 8 shows slides from his training presentation and the mockup paddle props he provided. Figure 9 displays an example assessment checklist for the activity.

Slide title: Learning Outcomes
                            At the end of this lesson you will be able to 
                            (bulleted list) Explain the important of High visibility apparel
                            Demonstrate the stop, release, slow traffic procedures
                            Slide title: Flagger signals With a STOP/SLOW Paddle
                            Three drawings of a flagger:
                            Displaying a stop sign and holding her hand up in stop gesture (labeled STOP)
                            Displaying a slow sign and sweeping her hand over her shoulder to indicate drive on (labeled RELEASE)
                            Displaying a slow sign and lowering her hand in a slow gesture (labeled SLOW)
                            Stop and Slow Paddles

Source: Baltodano (2019).

Figure 8: Performance outcomes, directions, and props from “Flagger Certification Training Course”
Flagger Sign Assessment sheet
                            Date: __________
                            Eight column table with 4 rows:
                            Column headings: Name, Stop (subdivided into Paddle, Hand), Release (subdivided into Paddle, Hand), Slow (subdivided into Paddle, Hand), Pass/Fail
                            Row 1: Participant A: X,X, blank, X, X, X, Fail
                            Row 2: Participant B: X,X, X, X, X, X, Pass
                            Row 3: Participant C: X,X, X, X, X, X, Pass
                            Row 4: Participant D: X,X, X, X, X, X, Pass

Source: Baltodano (2019).

Figure 9: Assessment checklist for “Flagger Certification Training Course”